Your chance to comment on a Department of Homeland Security plan to tap into state drivers’ license databases and create a new national ID system expires next week. It’s the groundwork for a cardless national ID, which threatens liberty even more than card-based schemes like REAL ID.
The E-Verify program’s move to merge federal background checks and state driver license data sets the stage for satisfying all three elements of a national ID. (Two years ago, I discussed what constitutes a national ID in some detail.) E-Verify has not satisfied these criteria up to now, but the pieces are coming together quickly.
First, it is national. That is, it is intended to be used throughout the country, and to be nationally uniform in its key elements. If its proponents have their way, E-Verify will indeed soon go national, a requirement on every employer to vet new workers past the federal government’s databases.
Second, its use is either practically or legally required. This is a judgment call, but in two diferent ways, E-Verify appears to meet this element. First, not having data in the E-Verify databases means not having legal work, so “participation” in E-Verify can be fairly called practically required. Second, try to opt out of the system and you will meet a dead end. The program includes no opportunity I know of to refuse participation. It’s legally required if the state or federal governments have got your identity data.
I could be wrong, of course. Interested researchers should try contacting their state motor vehicle bureaus (cc: your state legislators) and ask not to have data about you transferred to the federal government for E-Verify. Please let me know what you learn.
The final “element” of a national ID is that it is used for identification. Up to now, E-Verify has largely worked by comparing identifiers. (I.e., Does this name match this Social Security number?) The current plan is to tap into state databases for more identifiers: name, date of birth, driver’s license/permit number, and so on. From there, it’s a short ride to gathering drivers’ license photos and biometric descriptors. (E-Verify already uses federally acquired photos in its “Photo Screening Tool.” With the inclusion of your driver’s license photo, the E-Verify system will be able to display your picture on the screen of anyone who looks you up, allowing for positive identification.
This is a national identification system. If every employer has to use E-Verify—or even every major employer—it will become the all-purpose security device, used for cashing checks, confirming the name on credit cards, and looking you up at the prescription counter. Of course, it will be used at airport checkpoints. You’ll be screened through E-Verify at entrances to government buildings—maybe private buildings, too. And why not for random, “instant” checks at the subway or bus station?
Just remember: If you have a tax dispute with the government, the Department of Homeland Security might flag you in the database—or it might de-identify you entirely—until you get right with the government.
Because it’s a database system, you won’t be able to argue your case like you can in the familiar card environment. With a card, at least, you can say, “No, look. This is me. This is my ID card. This is my picture. Give me my prescription.” With E-Verify, the answer will be, “Sorry, you have to talk to DHS or Social Security.” For good reason, I named my paper on electronic employment eligibility verification, “Franz Kafka’s Solution to Illegal Immigration.”
I went through the arguments against having a national identification system in my book, Identity Crisis. In brief, a national ID would strip us of privacy even faster than is already happening, producing formal dossiers and increased surveillance. A national ID would transfer power en masse from individuals to governments. They would administer our rights by controlling the tools we need to navigate a “papers, please” society. A national ID would also be insecure, as it centralizes and homogenizes information assets (identity data) that are more secure if widely dispersed and heterogeneous.
Jim Harper • June 1, 2011 @ 3:57 pm
Filed under: Cato Publications; Telecom, Internet & Information Policy
Tags: E-Verify, national id, real id
GOD'S WORD FOR TODAY
Blessed are they that keep his testimonies, and that seek him with the whole heart. Psalm 119:2 KJV
IN THE NEWS
'Serious doubts' that Obama a friend of Israel
POLICE STATE NEWS
Fallout from RNC lawsuits: $175,000 so far in settlements
Fears of a corporate police state
Illegal drugs and terrorists create an American police state
"It's official: America is now a police state with the help of the liberal mainstream media" by Waging Peace
Secrecy Bill Is Required By An Elite Unconcerned With National Security
Michigan State Police go high-tech
Boston police seek jurisdiction over waterfront area
Texans Demand State Resist Obama DOJ & TSA Bullying
Don't give up your rights
Police state doesn't want dancing at the Jefferson Memorial
Next It Could Be You
One Week in the Life of a Police State
Obama Signs Extension of Patriot Act Spy Powers
Helmet Cam on Sherrif Dupnik's SWAT Team Shows Moment Iraq Vet Was Gunned Down
Supreme Court ruling made Indiana a police state
Supreme Court ruling made Indiana a police state
Zero tolerance derails student's plans
FBI: Webcams Pose Spying Danger
DHS Grants Will Pay For Surveillance Systems
US Police State Begins Exponential Expansion
Senate Approves 4-Year Extension of PATRIOT Act
Feds to require black box event recorders in all new cars
'US turning into police state'
Supreme Courts Affirm The Police State
What's so patriotic about the Patriot Act? ...
A chance to put protections in the Patriot Act
Congress has midnight deadline on Patriot Act
Google, Facebook warn on Internet rules at e-G8
US to store passenger data for 15 years
Quincy police stage mock school shooting drill
Senate holds sanctuary cities bill hostage until security bill passes
American police state strides forward
This Is What A Police State Looks Like
Torture and imprisonment of Egypt protesters still rife, says human rights activist
REAL ID & PRIVACY NEWS
California DMV Employees Accused of Illegally Using Handicapped Placards
National ID Card of INdia Same As US National ID Card
The New Cardless! National ID
WI - Your license: Made in California
VA DMV halts computer systems redesign
State unveils new digital driver license
Henderson man arrested in driver's license scam
National ID, Misguided State Legislation, the Clintons and E-Verify: What do they have in Common?
One Place Rapture Apparently Did Hit: The D.C. DMV
Voters who register sans driver's licenses give info that doesn't match their own SSA records
Queen of the Road: DMV late on 850,000 licenses, and another Queen contest
Video: In Real ID Protest, Florida Libertarian Chairman Drives Without a License
Mississippi driver's license information to be used for immigration enforcement
Driver's data may be used to check workers' status - For EVerify
California DMV Employees Reportedly Parking Illegally With Handicapped Placards
Why Should State Waste Money Pursuing 'Real ID'?
POLITICS & GOVERNMENT
Protesters disrupt budget committee meeting, several carried out
Romney labeled as 'cultural liberal'
Liberals dominate grad speaker list
Obama heads to Ohio to defend record, reach voters
Is America Ready for 'WeinerGate'?
China 'setting up military cyber-warfare team'
Washington's not scared by China's inroads in Latin America - FTAA
Ron Paul leads Sarah Palin and Mitt Romney in Republican (book) race
NY rep hires lawyer after lewd photo posted online
Oklahoma OKs 'Health Care Compact'
Cash for tax cheats
The money-grubbing government among us
Some Thoughts on the IMF, Global Injustice, and a Stranger on a Train
What do Pawlenty's executive orders tell us about his executive tendencies?
Should Kagan recuse herself?
Let’s Bury These Phony Myths About World War II
Court nullifies 4th Amendment protections going back to Magna Carta
Supreme Court Declines to Rule on Fourth Amendment Rights in Child Abuse Interviews
Military's religious liberties a concern
Jerusalem -- the 'new Berlin'?
Government Cannot Be Trusted To Police Itself
State Officials Need'nt Heed Feds Threats
State Sen. Steve Harrelson involved in domestic dispute
Auto bailout 'worth every penny'?
No more raises for poor-performing federal workers?
John Edwards 'to be prosecuted for using campaign funds for hush money'
Police and fire fighters now have to pay more for pensions and health insurance
Weak data point to sluggish U.S. economy
Home Prices in U.S. Probably Kept Falling as Housing Absent From Recovery
Surviving the Chaos - A Guide to Preparation for National Turmoil
Stimulus took more jobs than it created
Foreclosures Weigh on Home Prices
Indiana arguing state's rights
The nearly aborted president
Defunding abortuaries not OK with feds
Home Depot displays deaf ear
Punishment for blocking 'gay' adoptions
Mosquitos Prefer Beer Drinkers
EVERIFY & IMMIGRATION NEWS
Alabama Legislature passes Arizona-style immigration bill
Tennessee Legislature Passes "Non-Mandatory" E-Verify Law
Civil rights groups file lawsuit, challenging Georgia's new illegal immigration law
Immigration: You can't rely on E-Verify
E-Verify and Common Sense
E-Verify ruling affirms burden on business
North Carolina Bill Heats Up Immigration Debate
Obama and Immigration
Drivers License Information to be added to Mississippi E-Verify
Supreme Court immigration law ruling renews push for mandatory E-Verify system
Mississippi To Be Testing Ground for New Immigration Status Checks With Driver License Data
Driver's data may be used to check workers' status
Feds not helping SC find illegal workers
High Court's Immigration Ruling Shines Light On 'E-Verify'
Driver's data may be used to check workers' status
Arizona immigration law ruling: You can't rely on E-Verify
Driver's Data May be Used to Check Workers' Status
Potential Florida ramifications in Supreme Court ruling on E-Verify
Tennessee Lawful Employment Act Requiring E-Verify Use by Employers Passes House
Secure Communities program: A flawed deportation tool
E-Verify Passes Tennessee House
Politicians sell out citizens for illegal aliens
New Georgia law will require employers to use E-Verify
States' immigration efforts fizzle
Louisiana and Pennsylvania Senates Pass Bills Requiring State Contractors to Use E-Verify
The Truth About E-Verify
Mandatory E-Verify would harm the economy
Immigration reform hot topic for state legislatures
PA Senate passes E-Verify plan for contractors
Supreme Court upholds Ariz. law punishing companies that hire illegal immigrants
Wandering Toddler Prompts Parents' Arrests In Griswold
Joplin, Mo: Shame On Cnn
TV Executives Admit in Taped Interviews That Hollywood Pushes a Liberal Agenda
MADE IN THE USA
Rep. Fattah Calls on the President for an Order to Spur Domestic Manufacturing by Government Contractors
U.S. manufacturing economy heading in the wrong direction
9 Cars That Can Rebuild The American Auto Industry
U.S. Manufacturer of NEX Toys Offers Contract Manufacturing Services
Made in Connecticut: State Pushes for More Manufacturing Jobs
Middle class vulnerable to offshoring jobs
Manufacturing renaissance probable?
How Manufacturing Jobs Could Be Returning Home To The U.S.
The American Manufacturing Success Story: Writing the Next Chapter
Stimulate manufacturing to boost jobs, NAM chief says
Olsen Twins Use Made-in-America Hook to Lure Wealthy Shoppers
Worries of Resurgent US Manufacturing Tanking Again Soon
Youngstown News, Ryan, colleague launch website to aid rebirth of US manufacturing
Outsourcing manufacturing hurts U.S.
Is Michigan ready for manufacturing's comeback?
Maine home to last US athletic shoemaker
Bring back US's manufacturing power
China To Lose Edge Over U.S. By 2016, Economist Says
Buy Made in America Products
Make It in America: Rep. Tom Graves Becomes the Voice of Manufacturing
Alaska is only state to avoid U.S. manufacturing decline
We can build it
Keen On Home Grown U.S. Footwear Production
Homeland Security/OSHA Gov. Goons infiltrating US Manufacturing?
MAG begins U.S. manufacturing/sales of c-Si solar panel production lines with capacities up to 130 MWp
In The Wake Of Weinergate, Hackers Weigh In On Twitter's Vulnerability To Hacking
Yahoo and hotmail are also targeted by spear phishing hackers
Gmail hack underscores White House email risk
Hackers steal user data for 1 million Sony Pictures users
MI6 hackers replace bomb recipes with cake recipes
Gmail Hackers Phished Victims for Months
Rsa secureid hackers are linked to a third military contractor hack
Hackers attack another Sony network, post data
Facebook Video Scam Infects Mac And Windows
Amazon Cloud Might Be a Hacker Magnet
Hackers stole secret Canadian government data
China Google hackers' goal: Spying on U.S. Govt.
Hackers Target Social-Network Accounts
Internet insecurity: Once more unto the breach
Nude Photo Hackers Taunt Blake Lively, Release More Shots
Netizens speculate next target as hackers rule corporations world over
Hackers quickly bypass Apple's malware defenses
Google says hackers based in China accessed U.S. officials Gmail accounts
China rejects Google allegation of massive hacking breach as fabrication
Cybersecurity becoming U.S. diplomatic priority
PlayStation News: Hackers threaten more Sony online attacks
Pentagon Declares Cyber Hacks Acts of War
Microsoft decides to take it easy on hackers
Hackers Use Cloud Computing to Boost Firepower
Will hardware hackers build hidden devices to distort news at Wi-Fi hotspots?
Hackers are developing firefox scareware tricks
Hackers nab data on nearly 300,000 Canadian Honda owners
Hackers Break Into Fox News Feed, Accusing Network Of Trying to Kill Our Unions
'Cyber attacks are an act of war': Pentagon to issue new rules against hackers'
Tenn. passes Web entertainment theft bill
Hackers target IMF over Greece treatment
Google Says It Uncovered Attempt to Steal Users Gmail Account Passwords
Major weapons makers see networks breached by hackers
Lockheed, PBS Join Roster of Hacking Victims
Hackers Hit U.S. Army Contractors
Anthony Weiner: Hackers posted lewd photos on Twitter
Sony chief Stringer blindsided by hacker groups seeking revenge
Why Can't Japanese Companies Keep Their Data Secure?
Winnipeg woman fends off 'scary' hacker
Porn Twittergate has Rep. Weiner hacked off
The Trouble With E-Mail
PBS Website Hacked
Lockheed Martin Network Suffers Security Breach
Hackers hit U.S. defense contractors
Hackers breached U.S. defense contractors
The Price of Hackers, Spammers and Abuse: When Is It Too Much?
State Officials Needn't Heed Feds Threats
Honda Canada tells customers that hackers stole some personal data
Hackers release Mac Guard fake AV software as Apple releases OS X update
How 'cookiejacking' could steal people's Facebook passwords
Lockheed Martin: Cyber attack halted
Hackers protesting Nigeria's budget, inauguration spending shut down gov't website
State highway police website hacked
Another Sony online database is hacked
Hacker Liability: How at Risk is Your Company?
Hacker attack to cost Sony $172 million, almost as much as initial Japanese earthquake damage
Hackers creating fake boarding passes
Six Ways to Protect Yourself From Online Hackers
Hacked Canonical Tags: Coming Soon To A Website Near You?
More sophisticated hackers mean we must be more alert
Jude Law's High Court lawsuit against News of the World 'phone hackers' will be compensation test case
Norwegian military targeted by hackers
Hackers hit Sony sites raising more security issues
The hackers always win
Hackers Infiltrate Sony So-net Subsidiary, Steal $1,125 in Points
'I was destroyed by Murdoch's hackers,' says svengali
PlayStation Network users still under-threat as hackers have enough information to alter passwords
Meet This 14-Year-Old Self Taught Hacker
Sony must secure networks, analysts say
LinkedIn slashes cookie lifespan after research exposes security flaws
Sony Hacked Again... and Again
Hackers: 'Stupid Sony, so very stupid'
Cyber-Hackers: Faster, Better Equipped Than You
Sony Greek Website Is Latest To Be Hacked
Firms learn they're never too small to be hit by cyber attack
Hackers target student group websites
Sony's new security plan: so many flaws hackers tire before hitting them all
Don't be next Sony PlayStation - protect your customers data
LinkedIn 'vulnerable to to attack by hackers'
Six new tricks from hackers
Oklahoma City using SIEM to crack down on hackers
Hackers Hit At Sony Sites
America's Cyber Threat' serves as warning against invasive website hackers
Sony Suspends Canada, Thai Web Pages as Cyber Attacks Spread
Lesson Learned from Sony PSN Attack: Secure Your Log Data
Microsoft latest security risk: 'Cookiejacking'
Unknown Facebook 'friend' may be hacker
Macs a 'soft target' for viruses and hackers, security firms say
Microsoft finds 427K email addresses on knocked-out Rustock server
Sony Music Japan, Sony Ericsson hacked
Businesses most at risk from Web hackers
Hackers Steal Hotmail Messages Thanks to Web Flaw
Sony suffers hacker attack in Canada
Businesses most at risk from Web hackers
Sony says hacker stole 2,000 records from Canadian site
LinkedIn Faces Cookie Vulnerabilities