Live Free Radio Keep Living Free

Will the Show-Me State Show Us How to Nullify ObamaCare?

Michael Tennant | The New American
Sunday, 01 August 2010

The growing movement for state nullification of ObamaCare may get another boost on August 3. Missouri’s primary election, to be held on Tuesday, August 3, includes a ballot question asking voters if state law should be amended to “deny the government authority to penalize citizens for refusing to purchase private insurance or infringe upon the right to offer or accept direct payment for lawful health care services.”

According to a July 31 New York Times report, the initiative is part of a campaign by a conservative group called the American Legislative Exchange Council, which has already succeeded in getting similar measures enacted by legislatures in Arizona, Georgia, Idaho, Louisiana, and Virginia. In addition, Arizona and Oklahoma have state constitutional amendments to nullify the individual mandate on their November general election ballots. (Florida had one as well, but a judge threw it off the ballot because he thought the wording of the amendment’s explanation was misleading.)

Missouri’s question ended up in the primary election as a result of a compromise between Republican and Democratic state legislators. Explains the Times: “The Democrats agreed not to filibuster if the referendum was held during the August primary rather than the November general election, said State Senator Jane Cunningham, a Republican who sponsored the bill. With an open seat for the Senate on the line, the Democrats did not want to encourage heavy turnout among conservatives in November.” The referendum approach also had the advantage of not requiring the Democratic governor’s signature, unlike actual legislation.

The Times reports that the campaign in favor of Proposition C, as the referendum is known, “has been a low-key affair, with no television advertising, debates or celebrity Facebook endorsements.”

A group known as Missourians for Health Care Freedom, says the paper, “raised $75,000 as of July 24, enough for radio advertising, yard signs and get-out-the-vote telephone banks, but not enough for television commercials.” The group’s radio ad asks, “Do you think Washington knows what’s best for you and your family?”

Meanwhile, adds the Times, “The only organized opposition — beyond a Facebook page — has been mounted by the Missouri Hospital Association, which has spent more than $400,000 to send mailings to hundreds of thousands of homes, according to financial disclosure reports. The brochures warn that approval of Proposition C could burden hospitals, and their insured patients, with the cost of uncompensated care for people without health coverage.” A spokesman for the hospital association told the newspaper, “There’s an argument that a vote for Proposition C is a vote in support of freeloaders,” though he admitted that “we don’t want it perceived that we’re opposing it.”

Interestingly, while the hospital association, which stands to benefit financially from ObamaCare, is opposing Proposition C, the Missouri State Medical Association, which represents doctors, is supporting it. Doctors, of course, recognize many of the inherent problems with ObamaCare, most especially its rending of the doctor-patient relationship and replacing it with a bureaucrat-patient relationship — and all the additional red tape it means for their offices.

As a full-throated supporter of ObamaCare, the Times does its best to minimize the importance of the referendum and to portray it as nothing but a GOP ploy. The very first paragraph of the Times’ supposedly objective story declares that the vote “seems likely to be a low-turnout affair among an electorate dominated by Republican primary voters and conservative activists.” It later says the referendum “is seen as an organizational test for the Tea Party and like-minded conservatives” and quotes the executive director of the Missouri Democratic Party, who claims the proposition is “a ploy by the Republicans to get their base excited.”

Undoubtedly politics plays into it — indeed, as mentioned above, the very timing of the referendum was the result of a political deal — but surely the fact that a significant number of voters and state legislators believe that their state needs to take a stand against overweening Washington control suggests that there is more to it than simply politics.

Speaking at a rally for Proposition C, State Senator Jim Lembke, a Republican, indicated what that “more” is: “This health care thing is just a vehicle, a vehicle for the debate about what is the role of the federal government and what is the role of the states.” That is, does the Constitution — particularly the Ninth and Tenth Amendments — really mean what it says, or can the federal government overrule it simply by passing a law?

Clearly not everyone thinks the Constitution should be declared legally dead yet. The Times notes that “elected officials in 22 states, almost all Republicans, have filed lawsuits challenging the so-called individual insurance mandate. Among them, Virginia has made a direct claim that the federal law conflicts with its own 2010 statute, which asserts that residents of the commonwealth cannot be compelled to obtain health insurance.” Missouri’s own lieutenant governor, a Republican, is the most recent state official to file suit against the mandate.

The virtue of state legislation, as opposed to lawsuits, is that it can also prevent states from enacting their own individual mandates if ObamaCare is declared unconstitutional or is repealed. Recall that the Missouri question asks for state law to deny “the government” — all levels, not just the federal — the authority to force people to buy health insurance.

Of course, as opponents of Proposition C pointed out to the Times, even if the proposition passes, it doesn’t mean Missouri law will actually change to reflect that. It is merely a statement by the voters that the law should be amended to nullify the individual mandate; it doesn’t force the state to do so.

Still, as the paper says, supporters of the proposition believe that “a substantial victory … will convey a message of discontent with expansive federal government and rally other states and candidates to press the issue through the fall campaign.”

As one who would like to see many other states follow the lead of those who have already voted to nullify at least part of ObamaCare, this author says to Missourians: Show me how it’s done on Tuesday.

SOURCE:
www.thenewamerican.com

IN THE NEWS
OIL SPILL 2010

US petrol stations to consider banishing BP from the pumps
http://bit.ly/aBkM0a

Worst job on Earth: BP calling all applicants
http://bit.ly/cqYY01

3 squabbling companies must cooperate to plug well
http://yhoo.it/9ibgLO

OBAMA NATION
MO ballot measures tests federal health care law
http://bit.ly/c8bWuv

Iran's President Ahmadinejad challenges Barack Obama to TV debate
http://bit.ly/d6drz5

Oops! Obama mama passport 'destroyed'
http://bit.ly/doc3rZ

Obamacare Supporter Stark: Feds Can Do Anything
http://bit.ly/cpsLNc

POLICE STATE NEWS

Why go after the criminals when you can just kill the messengers?
http://bit.ly/9kgMws

Minority Report Ad Billboards To Address Consumers By Name
http://bit.ly/akGuOO

Feds raid Amish dairy and threaten action over raw milk sales
http://bit.ly/c6tc7q

Chinese Online Game Law Requires Real-name Registration
http://bit.ly/aaLG7g

REAL ID & PRIVACY NEWS

Sites Feed Personal Details To New Tracking Industry
http://bit.ly/c2hgRr

Is Your Detergent Stalking You?
http://bit.ly/cVI0dn

Biometric and Other Locks Fail to Foil Hackers at DefCon
http://bit.ly/bVsNHX

Contest finds workers at big firms handing data to hackers
http://bit.ly/djaNSD

Manatee Clerk of Courts Announces Big Passport Fee Increase
http://bit.ly/cHNxwg

POLITICS & GOVERNMENT

Dumbing-Down Society Part 3: How to Reverse its Effects
http://bit.ly/cVPKb0

TAKE ACTION Tell Congress Pass the 72-hour rule
http://bit.ly/dtAwWL

Anti-SB1070 protesters desecrate American Flag
http://bit.ly/bZWFMv

Speaker Pelosi wants pre-election tax cut vote
http://bit.ly/cW02oW

GA Democratic candidate dodges Obama
http://bit.ly/cvLNta

Pelosi strikes confident note on midterms: 'I'm not nervous at all'
http://bit.ly/cab4X2

'Undead Zombie Option' resurrected in Congress
http://bit.ly/du05f2

Democrat-backed terror bill would ‘gut Miranda rights’
http://bit.ly/bEMp4O

The Mandatory Service Bill and the Impending Attack On Iran
http://bit.ly/9JQnma

Michele Bachmann Hospitalized
http://bit.ly/bSFkfY

Witness says WikiLeaks investigators sought to limit disclosure
http://bit.ly/arBKca

ECONOMIC NEWS

Watching The Fed Control the Economy
http://bit.ly/cJqNBl

Let Them Eat Cake
http://bit.ly/c5QRR8

Layoffs to gut East St. Louis police force
http://bit.ly/aBpysN

CA DMV announces Friday office closures in Aug, many services are available online
http://exm.nr/bNNtTs

40 Bizarre Statistics That Reveal The Horrifying Truth About The Collapse Of The U.S. Economy
http://bit.ly/aS4g7V

HEALTH NEWS

Media Whores Promote Eugenics! Lets Start Killing Grannies!
http://bit.ly/bSGT93

Doctor gagged for doubting shaken baby syndrome
http://bit.ly/cQ2CVm

Flu vaccine push already underway; first batch causes seizures in children
http://bit.ly/bq4K9T

Oxford Professor Calls for Mass Drugging Population Through Water Supply
http://bit.ly/9Cs837

After Stroke Scans, Patients Face Serious Health Risks
http://nyti.ms/d8Xy12

IMMIGRATION & BORDER NEWS

Our Own Government Has Become Our Enemy
http://bit.ly/d7JYSe

Utah children's social security numbers still being used by illegal immigrants
http://bit.ly/9I348V

Mexican Drug Cartel Allegedly Puts a Price on Arizona Sheriff's Head
http://bit.ly/bSGzPt

States rethink illegal immigrant bills after Arizona ruling
http://bit.ly/brEcGw

U.S. officials boost efforts to protect immigrant crime victims
http://bit.ly/9rZJ9X

Illegal Aliens' Kids Shouldn't Be Citizens
http://bit.ly/cSCM6V

MILITARY NEWS

Accused Fort Hood Shooter Nidal Hasan Can't Find a Bank Willing to Cash His Checks
http://bit.ly/clfIWZ

MORAL DECLINE

Teacher Faces Sex Assault Charge For Allegedly Spanking Student
http://bit.ly/atgvjK

Court won't keep woman who starved a daughter from new baby
http://bit.ly/dzcaFD

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY

Hacker builds $1,500 cell-phone tapping device
http://yhoo.it/ay80dd

Internet Addresses Will Run Out In A Year
http://bit.ly/a1xUF2

Researcher detained at U.S. border, questioned about Wikileaks
http://bit.ly/93MHr3

Elite US cyber team courts hackers to fight terrorists
http://bit.ly/awIcWW

Cybercrime Costs Businesses Big Bucks
http://bit.ly/cnS5Rx

Microsoft to Patch Hackers' "Shortcut" into Your Windows System Today
http://bit.ly/aZJWIB

Reformed hacker reveals My life as a spyware developer
http://bit.ly/a1gL4K

Researcher Warns of IE Auto-Complete Flaw
http://bit.ly/9GHxgQ

Hackers crack high-tech locks
http://bit.ly/bH9z2E

Hackers pick up where Facebook privacy leaves off
http://bit.ly/cwZD5U

Hackers Targeting Smartphone Apps
http://bit.ly/9nZxAt

Smooth-talking hackers test hi-tech titans' skills
http://bit.ly/dt7YJ5

Researchers Hack the Internet to Keep Us Safe
http://bit.ly/bURJxI